Locate an Agent:

Millville Gives Back: More Comfort. Greater Impact. Help provide infusion shirts for patients receiving cancer treatment this October. Millville Insurance will match your donation dollar for dollar. See how you can help.
Best's Review for Insurers

Standing the Test of Time


We are proud to be recognized by
A.M. Best for our long history of financial stability.

©A.M.Best – used with permission

Policyholder Comments

  • ERIE, PA Quick an easy process ~June, 2026
  • UNITYVILLE, PA I would like to say this is the first time that we've ever had to do with a clean for a home. my adjuster has been so professional and accommodating for all of our needs I would highly recommend your insurance company to anyone in the local area my adjuster made our horrible experience much better than expected thank you again for the service that your company provides. ~June, 2026
  • NORTHUMBERLAND, PA My adjuster did a fantastic job with helping with the situation to the best of his ability I appreciate the hard work and love dealing with this company you guys have always done good by me and have always recommended you guys as a company ~June, 2026
  • MARYSVILLE, PA My adjuster explained everything to me on my claim. He explained my deductible ,depreciation and was very clear on the process. I appreciate it the time he took to explain everything to me and the efficient manner which my claim was dealt with. ~March, 2026

Find an Agent

Millville Mutual is licensed to issue policies within the Commonwealth of PA.